I just finished
this book by
E. Lockhart. So good! I'd heard very good things about
The Disreputable History before I read it (like this
NPR recommendation by the author of
Book Lust,
Nancy Pearl), so I had very high expectations. When I got to the last third of the book, I started to really get what all the good reviews were talking about.
How do I even describe it? Let's start with the facts. Main character (you guessed it): Frankie Landau-Banks, a girl at an elite boarding school in northern Massachusetts. When she becomes aware of the presence of an active secret society on campus, she's first intrigued and then indignant. It's an all-male affair, one that has no room for her. That is, until she hatches a brilliant scheme.
And the brilliant scheme? That really hits its stride in the second half/last third of the book.
What I really loved about this book was its girl-power message. E. Lockhart did a wonderful job of describing what it's like to grow up girl. Wanting respect and caring/loving relationships at the same time. Feeling like you have so much to say but no one to hear you. Wanting to be seen and be a part of a world that excludes you.
This was no helpless heroine, and it also wasn't a caricature of a feminist, either. It seemed like a portrait of a real girl, one with a healthy sense of self, one caught between who the world was telling her to be and who she wanted to be.
And you know, reading this was an eye-opener. It made me realize how rare it is for a fiction book to openly discuss a girl/woman's place in society. The only examples I can think of off the top of my head are
Paper Towns and
Looking for Alaska by
John Green. In those, it never really gets thoroughly worked out, though, because narrators are boys. Don't get me wrong--these are great books, because the narrators are acknowledging that there are three-dimensional females in their lives, but you don't get inside the heads of the females actually having these thoughts.
So here's what I'm really trying to say: As someone who's been that girl struggling to feel like she's more than society says she is, I like this book. As someone who's been that girl unable to understand why, when she does speak up, she's either viewed as a cute, harmless, nearly invisible ladybug or as a trampling, destructive, hostile elephant, never just a person something important to say, I like this book. As someone who wants girls these days to know that they're not crazy for wanting to feel empowered, I like this book.
So
The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks? Highly recommended.
P.S.
New Moon Girls magazine is, in my opinion, the best place for young women to find support in growing up girl. It's aimed at a slightly younger audience than this book, though.